It is funny how each team seems to have their own unique problems and it's relatively consistent over multiple seasons.
Probably not an ideal scenario unless you are developing a goalie, but have you considered signing some scrub to play in the affiliate to act as a 2nd backup? When Amick needs a rest, which is often... and I mean OFTEN lmao, I'll recall Loiselle to play backup in case of goalie pull so that Amick doesn't get thrown into the game. Even some 78-79 guy for like 400K.
For what it's worth, the last place Alligators beat me earlier this season when they started their 78 overall goalie. It was a glorious moment for both teams.