Which pitcher is better? (made up players)

[ethan.lingle 0]

Left hander with a:

101mph 4 seam

94mph sinker

87mph slider 

or 

Right hander with a:

91mph slider

82mph screwball

92mph cutter

[rubis2006 0]

I would say the left hander.

[Unfunny 0]

The righty

[penthief 0]

Have to go with the lefty

[Jabez54 0]

The righty... the slider and the cutter are extremely tough to hit once master...